Skip to Main Content

KEYS to Teaching Success: Make Learning Relevant

Making Learning Relevant Overview

    Take a moment to imagine you are a third-grade teacher planning a lesson that addresses solving real-life mathematical problems involving time. The lesson will encourage students to solve meaningful problems that examine lapsed time, including time intervals to the hour, half-hour, and quarter-hour. You recently visited Atlanta, GA, to visit family, including your third-grade nephew. During your stay, you took your nephew to the Georgia Aquarium. For ease of navigating the city, you took MARTA (Metropolitan Atlanta Rapid Transit Authority). You took MARTA to the Five Points Station on the Blue/Green Line and walked fifteen minutes from the station to the Georgia Aquarium. Reflecting on this experience inspired you to write the following mathematics task:

Martha’s Adventure on MARTA
     Martha enjoys riding MARTA in Atlanta, GA. Her apartment is a 15-minute walk to the Inman Park-Reynoldstown Station. She wants to visit the Georgia Aquarium and take the train. She must catch the Blue Line three stops to the Five Points Station, which takes 5 minutes. Then, she must walk 15 minutes to the Georgia Aquarium.

     How much time will it take Martha to get to the Georgia Aquarium from her apartment if she takes MARTA and must wait 10 minutes to catch the train at the station?

     Martha plans to spend an hour and a half at the Georgia Aquarium. Assuming that the travel to and from the Georgia Aquarium is the same, how much total time does she spend on the entire trip?

     To your nephew and other students with background experience using MARTA or similar transit systems, this mathematics task could provide a meaningful and relevant problem to explore concepts of time. When planning a trip using city transit, students must consider travel time to and from a station, whether a train, streetcar, or bus, and calculate the time on the transit as well as the wait for the transit. If you teach students in a rural setting with little experience navigating different transit lines in the city, this problem may spark little interest and even evoke unnecessary confusion that distracts learners from the learning goal of solving real-life mathematical problems involving time. Thus, when planning lessons, it is crucial to consider the students you are teaching and what interests and experiences are important to them.      

     In her article “Keeping Learning Real, Relevant, and Relatable,” Grafwallner (2017) asserts, “Students want to learn about things that have an impact on them in their daily lives” (para. 2). The concept of “realness” Grafwallner refers to is also called authenticity or relevance. The significance of relevant learning is so paramount that the Georgia Professional Standards Commission identifies it a key criterion under InternKEYS Standard 1: “The teacher demonstrates an understanding of the curriculum, subject content, pedagogical knowledge and the needs of students by providing relevant learning experiences” (Georgia Professional Standards Commission, 2023).

     Teachers are trained to begin all planning with standards; in fact, content standards form the foundation for learning. Instructional decisions, which are at the heart of teaching, bring life to the classroom. As Ainsworth (2010) states, “The constant is the standard the variation is in the creative teaching of that standard” (p. 173). However, new teachers often struggle to find effective strategies for different grade levels and subject areas that make learning relevant to students. Fortunately, the InternKEYS rubric provides several examples, referred to as “performance indicators,” that teachers can use to demonstrate their combined professional knowledge sets. In addition to communicating clear student-friendly learning purposes [See "Stating Clear Meaningful Purposes"], we must instruct our students in ways that facilitate learning both inside and outside the classroom (Larson & Keiper, 2012). When executed effectively, the content is optimized and becomes meaningful and real. 

     We can approach instructional decisions by what Bishop (1990) describes as “mirrors” and “windows” with the student at the focal point. Mirrors are created from a student's knowledge of their own family, community, and culture, allowing them to see themselves reflected within the curriculum. This connection integrates a student’s prior and background knowledge and permits students to use unconventional examples that allow students to explain in ways that make sense to them. Conversely, windows offer students perspectives beyond their own experiences, introducing them to different locations, perspectives, and beliefs related to the content. In today’s classrooms, some students seldom encounter these mirrors and are given little time to look beyond the curriculum to learn from others. While time constraints will always exist, we can be strategic in planning lessons that help students better optimize and uncover their prior knowledge. To ensure students feel comfortable expressing themselves and learning ways to welcome new perspectives, we must create a learning environment that builds rapport and invites inclusivity where students feel comfortable sharing their experiences. Fostering a safe place for students to share and learn from one another will permit you and your students to make meaningful and relevant connections, which will not only engage students but also activate motivation and specific areas of the brain (Hammond, 2014). Performance indicator 1.3 identifies three ways we can help make concepts relatable: 

  • By connecting them to students’ previous learning experiences.
  • By connecting them to other academic subjects.
  • By connecting them to real-world situations.

Strategies

     When examining the connections between individual students and their existing knowledge, two key terms in pedagogical discussions must be considered. Prior knowledge refers to the information, facts, and experiences that support the educational content of a subject area. This foundational knowledge aids in building subject comprehension and higher-order thinking. As education spans a student's lifetime, prior knowledge of a content topic may be acquired through instructional lessons in previous grades, reading fiction and non-fiction texts, or experimenting with materials in a science lab. Conversely, background knowledge is derived from a student's language and experiences within their family, community, and culture. This knowledge may vary in vocabulary, familiarity with geographic regions, or ways of describing and interpreting emotions within a text. Background knowledge is unique to each child and represents their funds of knowledge and assets.

     Effective instruction should facilitate students’ discovery of relationships and patterns that build upon their prior knowledge (Jonson et al., 2010). These connections need not be complex; often, they can be established through simple activities such as graphic organizers, discussions, or stating learning objectives with a quick write. Pre-assessments, including informal surveys or brief learning hooks, can connect to previously learned concepts. Below are examples of pre-assessments at various grade levels:

  • An eleventh-grade literature teacher begins a unit with an informal survey titled, Are You a Transcendentalist? Questions enable students to assess their beliefs and personalities, which they later compare and contrast with the philosophies of American Transcendentalism.
  • A first-grade teacher begins a unit about American heritage by showing her students images of the faces on coins and dollar bills. She asks the students to choose one coin or bill and draw a full-body picture of the person depicted. She encourages students to reflect on and illustrate everything they know or think they know about that person in their drawing. Next, she asks the students to draw a picture of themselves and include details showing how their culture, family, and personal experiences have shaped who they are. Students must then share what symbols, objects, or background elements are added to the picture to represent their heritage and story. 
  • A fifth-grade physical education teacher asks small groups of students to brainstorm as many sports as possible that can be played indoors. She uses this collaborative activity to open a unit on indoor sports, such as badminton, volleyball, table tennis, and bowling. Students are then asked to share their experiences engaging in these indoor sports.
  • A third-grade teacher activates students’ prior knowledge of addition and subtraction by asking students to share their knowledge of pizza, its different sizes, and how it can be sliced. Students reflect on the size of the whole and their experience comparing and contrasting pizza sizes with how many slices they like to eat. 

     One benefit of pre-assessment activities is that they also help teachers get to know their students [See "Standard 7"], which in turn allows teachers to make future lessons relevant. However, connecting to prior learning can also occur in the middle of a lesson or during its closing. Critical thinking prompts, brief classroom assessments, small group discussions, and practice exercises can foster associations with concepts students learned in earlier units or the previous grades. The following examples might illustrate ways to incorporate prior concepts into a lesson:

  • An eleventh-grade U.S. history teacher helps her students examine American isolationism at the onset of World War II. During a discussion of the U.S. reluctance to interfere with Germany’s growing power in Europe, the teacher might want her students to compare that perspective to American isolationism prior to World War I. She could ask her students, “When did we see such reluctance before?”
  • A seventh-grade science teacher helps her students understand the seasons of the year. As students work with models, she instructs them to explain by harkening what they have already learned about the way the Earth rotates on its axis and the way the Earth revolves around the sun.
  • After demonstrating the correct procedure for serving a tennis ball, the P. E. teacher instructs students to practice. Following this, he prompts students to draw comparisons between the tennis serve and the badminton serve covered in the previous unit. Students must articulate how they apply similar and differing skills in each sport.

     Drawing upon students’ prior knowledge not only facilitates deeper connections to the content but also supports teachers in enhancing the relevance of the learning experience for students. Leveraging this approach promotes efficiency by tapping into the brain’s capacity to store memories and experiences, which unconsciously inform instructional strategies to connect emotions, behaviors, and cognitive demands within the classroom (Hammond, 2014). By understanding students’ existing background knowledge, we can strategically engage positive emotional responses while emphasizing certain concepts over others, thereby optimizing learning outcomes.

Please open the next tab: Connections to Other Disciplines

     As we integrate content with students’ prior knowledge, it is also imperative to forge connections across disciplines. Demonstrating these interconnections is crucial as it can be challenging to effectively teach a concept in isolation from its relevance to other subjects. While these intersections often naturally emerge during class discussions, deliberate efforts can be made through lesson planning to explicitly link multiple content areas, thereby enriching the learning experience with meaningful and relevant connections.

     When exploring ways to foster interdisciplinary connections, it is valuable to consider research on transfer—the process through which individuals acquire knowledge and skills in one content area and apply that knowledge to novel situations. Transfer is essential for prompting higher-order thinking, including problem-solving and creative thinking. Within a classroom context, transfer can occur both during the learning process and during subsequent application. During learning, transfer is facilitated by techniques such as activating prior knowledge and vocabulary, establishing connections across related contexts, and using visual and verbal cues to link terms and content. Examples include drawing explicit parallels, employing similes and metaphors, utilizing concept maps, encouraging reflection, and adopting a thematic approach to teaching. To extend transfer beyond immediate lessons, instruction should aim to cultivate higher-order thinking skills, such as considering multiple perspectives, fostering conceptual understanding, and making explicit connections to real-world context. This approach supports students in applying their learning in meaningful and impactful ways across various disciplines. 

     In recent years, there has been a growing interest among educators in exploring the interconnectedness of STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) and the humanities. Concurrently, the STEAM approach (STEM with Art) acknowledges the inherent synergy between arts and sciences. While thematic learning often integrates these disciplines effectively in elementary education, achieving similar integration in middle and high school can be challenging due to compartmentalized subject areas. By embracing interdisciplinary overlaps, students enhance their critical thinking abilities and develop skills in generating creative solutions to complex problems (Dubek et al., 2021; Khine & Areepattamannil, 2019). STEAM education typically involves collaborative teaching units across multiple subject teachers, yet it also manifests within individual classrooms. Examples include an ELA teacher incorporating science writing activities or a mathematics teacher guiding students to apply geometric principles in designing mazes for rodents.

     In elementary grades, STEAM learning “falls under the umbrella of inquiry instruction,” which “encourages active (often hands-on) experiences that support building understanding and vocabulary, critical thinking, problem solving, communication and reflection” (Linder & Eckhoff, 2020, para. 1). Activities could involve instructing students in charting and illustrating weekly summaries of weather patterns, including cloudy, rainy, and sunny days (Linder & Eckhoff, 2020). Another example includes projects where students are asked to solve a problem, such as fair use of the science station. Lessons may be designed to encourage children to propose organizational solutions for materials and engage in role-playing scenarios to practice effective communication when multiple students require access to the same resources.

     For middle grades students, STEAM instruction can foster students’ “divergent tasks,” which are those that have students “generat[ing] several ideas about possible ways to solve problems” and that “have no unique solution” (Sousa & Pilecki, 2018, p. 37). An example of a divergent task could be seen in a solar system unit, where students explore various planets, their sizes, distances from the sun, and proximity to other planets. The creative and artistic component of this unit could involve students selecting a planet and creating a detailed illustration and description of a hypothetical creature capable of surviving on that planet, considering factors such as oxygen levels, gravity, surface temperature, and other environmental conditions. In another instance, within a government class, students might analyze different candidates’ rhetorical strategies throughout an election campaign. As part of this study, students could be tasked with writing and delivering their own speeches, applying the rhetorical techniques they have studied to effectively communicate their ideas and positions.

     Works of literature raise valuable opportunities for cross-disciplinary conversations. Agrawal et al. (2021) suggest the following ways literature can be used:

  • Mathematics teachers can integrate literature to teach various mathematics concepts, which can appeal to students who may lack confidence in their mathematics skills and invite opportunities to position mathematics in a context of interest. 
  • When studying Lee’s (1960) To Kill a Mockingbird, students can engage with probability and statistics while exploring themes of race and inequality.
  • Born a Crime: Stories from a South African Childhood by Trevor Noah (2019) could offer students insights into apartheid history while providing opportunities for students to develop skills in writing business plans.
  • Through Lewis’ The Chronicles of Narnia, beginning with The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe (1950), students can explore how people might betray others for power while also learning about the research methods involved in tracking and forecasting weather patterns.

Please open the next tab: Connections to Real-World Experiences

     The aforementioned examples of STEAM instruction illustrate practical applications of concepts in real-world contexts. By demonstrating the utility of these concepts, educators equip students with valuable tools to navigate a complex world and broaden their perspectives. Understanding our students [See "Standard 7"] allows us to establish meaningful connections, and as we cultivate relationships with them, we can further align academic concepts with the issues and questions that resonate with their interests and concerns. 

     Sometimes, current events, both good and bad, establish that relevance for us. Many news outlets, such as New York Times, PBS Newshour, NBC, Discovery Education, and CNN offer programming and publications targeting young audiences. Helping students follow the news can reinforce the real-world implications of the concepts they examine in the classroom. For instance, biology, mathematics, and health teachers could design lessons involving public health charts and maps tracking the virus’s spread during the COVID pandemic. The pandemic also helped health and science teachers emphasize the importance of vaccines. As another example, political science teachers can design lessons centered on candidates’ campaign rhetoric and performance, incorporating current events related to elections, history, government, and English language arts. This approach allows students to engage critically with political discourse and form their own informed opinions. 

     We can foster real-world connections by helping students understand the reasons behind their community’s processes and decisions (Thompson, 2018). Inviting guest speakers from local weather services or emergency management agencies, for instance, can help students grasp how scientific knowledge informs urban planning decisions, such as street and sidewalk construction, as well as zoning regulations for residential buildings. Similarly, interactions with local city council members or municipal staff provide insights into the broader impacts of local governance, spanning from neighborhood policies to statewide and even national issues.

     Additionally, field trips and project-based or place-based learning offer valuable opportunities to connect academic concepts with real-world experiences. Georgia's rich history and diverse natural resources provide ample opportunities for educators to organize authentic learning experiences within their school districts. For instance, visits to Georgia's marble mines, extensive marshlands, Okefenokee Swamp, and national forests offer students engaging opportunities to actively explore and learn about the state's natural resources. Educational excursions to historical sites such as the Little White House, the Carter Center, the Martin Luther King, Jr. Center, and the town of Plains provide insights into Georgia's contributions to state and federal governance. By visiting Georgia’s many museums [See "Make Learning Relevant Examples"], students can delve into the arts, sciences, and history. These experiences not only enhance academic learning but also foster a deeper appreciation and understanding of Georgia’s cultural and natural heritage.

     In instances where budgetary or time constraints limit physical visits, museum websites and virtual field trips leveraging digital resources offer valuable avenues for remote learning and student engagement. In our dynamic, technology-driven world, organizations and partnerships have made virtual field trips possible to bring immersive experiences to all learners. These experiences provide “windows” to diverse perspectives and multimodal learning opportunities that can ignite student motivation and deepen their understanding of various topics, whether exploring different regions within our state, country, or globally. 

     For example, utilizing tools like Google Earth can enrich a middle school social studies curriculum by allowing students to investigate geographical distances, city sizes, and historical landmarks worldwide. Similarly, live streams from institutions such as the Georgia Aquarium can provide real-time data for mathematics lessons while offering glimpses into the diverse marine ecosystems housed there. Similarly, live streams from the Georgia Aquarium can assist in gathering real-time data for a mathematics lesson while offering glimpses into the diverse marine ecosystems housed there. For elementary classrooms studying Georgia's geographical regions, a virtual field trip to the Okefenokee Swamp introduces students to its unique plant and animal species, vividly bringing this natural environment to life in their imaginations. These virtual experiences not only supplement classroom learning but also broaden students' perspectives and deepen their appreciation for the world around them.

     Thompson (2018) argues that students engage more deeply with academic content when it resonates with their “interests, hobbies, experiences, or cultures” (p. 90). Establishing these connections enhances our understanding of students, empowering us to make learning experiences more meaningful. As you progress through your field placement(s), it will be essential for you to demonstrate how your instruction aligns with students’ prior knowledge, connects with other subjects, and relates to real-world experiences. Building these connections helps you show students how ideas that seem abstract in the classroom have actual, practical implications in their everyday lives. In short, such strategies make learning matter.

Assess Your Knowledge

Read the following teaching scenarios and select whether the teacher is making the concept relevant to (a) other disciplines, (b) to students’ prior learning, background knowledge, and content knowledge, or (c) to real-world experiences. Discuss your selection with a peer, your supervisor, or a colleague.


Question #1

Because a school resides close to an Air Force base, which employs many students’ parents, a mathematics teacher begins a lesson with a video explaining how airline pilots use mathematics to do their jobs. 
__ other disciplines     __ prior learning, background knowledge, and content knowledge     __ real-world experiences

 

Question #2

To add an enrichment aspect to her history class, a teacher assigns her students to read Kipling’s “Mary Postgate” and then places students in small groups to discuss how the scenes in the story match the concepts they have learned about in their current unit about World War I.
__ other disciplines    __ prior learning, background knowledge, and content knowledge    __ real-world experiences

 

Question #3

As part of a STEAM unit collaboration, an English Language Arts (ELA) teacher and a science teacher collaborated to design a project where students engage with segments of Homer’s The Iliad depicting the Greeks' invasion of Troy using the Trojan Horse. In addition to reading and discussing the literature, students will apply scientific principles to design a scale model of the horse, considering its size and structure to effectively conceal soldiers and infiltrate the city gates of Troy.
___ other disciplines    __ prior learning, background knowledge, and content knowledge       ___ real-world experiences

 

Question #4

To begin a new unit examining the plant and animal life of Georgia’s coastal plain, a third-grade teacher instructs her students to create a KWL (Know-Want to Know-Learned) chart. This activity prompts students to record what they already know about the topic and what they want to learn more about. Following this, the teacher organizes students into small groups to facilitate knowledge sharing and encourages them to suggest resources they can utilize to obtain the information they want to know.
___ other disciplines    __ prior learning, background knowledge, and content knowledge         ___ real-world experiences


Question #5

A fifth-grade health teacher designs a unit to enable students to “access valid information, products and services to enhance health” (standard HE5.3). She surveys students about their favorite cereals. Based on the survey results, the teacher selects the top three cereal brands and presents their nutritional charts to the class. Using the chart as a guide, the teacher asks students to explain the information they can interpret from the data provided. Building on students’ responses, the teacher then supplements their understanding by clarifying and introducing new information about how nutritional charts convey essential nutrients present in each cereal brand.
___ other disciplines    __ prior learning, background knowledge, and content knowledge            ___ real-world experiences

 

Click on the next tab to reveal the answers.

Question #1 - Real-World Experiences - The Air Base is located within proximity to the school. Students have familiarity with planes and jobs within the community. 

Question #2 - Other Disciplines - A literature text is used to provide context and different perspectives for the history lesson. 

Question #3 - Other Disciplines - By using scale and art, the text comes alive through different contexts. This is an interdisciplinary lesson.  

Question #4 - Prior learning, background knowledge, and content knowledge - The teacher activates prior knowledge through the KWL chart. Information is shared about what students know. 

Question #5 - Real-World Experiences - The activity mirror a real world context where indviduals assess the nutritional value of foods found in a local store. 

References

Agrawal, J., Hoag, G., Toms, O., Jolly, A., Reyes, E., & Voggt. (2021). Mathematics and literature. In G. Campbell-Whatley, D. Rodriguez, & J. Agrawal (Eds.), STEAM meets story: Using adolescent fiction and film to spark deeper learning (pp. 63–83). Teachers College Press.
Ainsworth, L. (2010). Rigorous curriculum design. Lead+Learn Press.
Bishop, R. S. (1990). Mirrors, windows, and sliding glass doors. Perspectives: Choosing and Using Books for the Classroom, 6(3), ix-xi.
Dubek, M., DeLuca, C., & Rickey, N. (2021). Unlocking the potential of STEAM education: How exemplary teachers navigate assessment challenges. Journal of Educational Research, 114(6), 513–525. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220671.202.1990002
Georgia Professional Standards Commission. (2023). Intern Keys (CAPS) Formative Observation Instrument. https://www.gapsc.com/EducatorPreparation/Data.aspx
Grafwallner, P. (2017, Nov. 2). Keeping learning real, relevant and relatable. Edutopiahttps://www.edutopia.org/article/keeping-learning-real-relevant-and-relatable
Hammond, Z. (2014). Culturally responsive teaching and the brain: Promoting authentic engagement and rigor among culturally and linguistically diverse students. Corwin. 
Jonson, K., Cappelloni, N., & Niesyn, M. (2010). The new elementary teacher’s handbook: Flourishing in your first year. Corwin.
Khine, M. S., & Areepattamannil, S. (2019). STEAM education: Theory and practice. Springer.
Larson, B., & Keiper, T. (2012). Instructional strategies for middle and high school. Taylor and Francis.
Lee, H. (1960). To kill a mockingbird. J. B. Lippincott & Co.
Lewis, C. S. (1950). The lion, the witch and the wardrobe. Godfrey Bles. 
Linder, S., & Eckhoff, A. (2020). Breaking down STEAM for young children. Teaching Young Children, 13(3).  https://www.naeyc.org/resources/pubs/tyc/feb2020/breaking-down-steam
Noah, T. (2019). Born a crime: Stories from a South African childhood. One World.
Sousa, D. A., & Pilecki, T. J. (2018). From STEM to STEAM: Brain compatible strategies and lessons that integrate arts. Corwin.
Thompson, J. (2018). The first-year teacher’s survival guide (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass.